top of page

How to identify an Authentic Montessori environment?

Updated: Mar 1

When schools affix the label 'Montessori' to their buildings, parents frequently struggle to assess the fidelity of their programs to the authentic Montessori method. Let's explore methods to verify their authenticity

Dr. Montessori formulated a comprehensive educational system spanning from infancy to 24 years through careful scientific observations of children. She initiated her work with the 3-6 age group in Casa dei Bambini, a method that remains widely embraced in early childhood education globally. However, Montessori's broader objective was to address the developmental needs of children from birth to adolescence. The educational model resulting from her life's work is structured around 3-year age groupings (0–3, 3–6, 6-9, 9-12, and so forth), facilitating self-directed learning within a meticulously prepared environment under the guidance of an adult. This approach ensures holistic support for children's intellectual, emotional, and social growth across all stages of their development.


In the past century, the Montessori method has gained global popularity. However, without trademark protection, it has faced significant distortions due to commercial interests, inadequate educator training, and lack of awareness among parents. Similarly, Yoga, originating in India as a spiritual practice, has also experienced distortions. Dr. Montessori meticulously developed her method based on child psychology, validated by over a century of practice. However, these distortions, often driven by purely commercial interests, fail to provide children the learning environment that Dr. Montessori envisioned to help children reach their full potential.


Dr. Montessori recognized the challenge for the method to stray from its principles over time. To safeguard the integrity of her approach, she established robust institutions during her lifetime. Over time, dedicated Montessorians further expanded these institutions, committed to preserving the essence of her educational movement. These establishments provide guidelines for creating genuine Montessori settings and offer rigorous training programs for adults, ensuring they are well-prepared to work within authentic Montessori environments. Below are the guidelines published by AMI (Association Montessori Internationale - a global institute headquartered in Netherlands. and constituted by Dr. Montessori in 1929 to develop her pedagogy and maintain standards):


1) Carefully Prepared Environment with full set of Montessori Materials covering all curriculum areas

Dr. Montessori developed specially-designed instructional materials based on her observations of children's developmental stages and their innate drive to learn from their environment. These materials, many of which are hand-made, are intended to introduce concepts about the world. Schools claiming to be Montessori must possess all necessary materials tailored to the age group they serve. Eg. there are over 300 activities available for the 3-6 age group in the learning environment accessible at all times. One common distortion occurs when schools reduce Montessori education to a small subset of materials they purchase, neglecting to create a comprehensive environment as prescribed by Dr. Montessori. These materials should be arranged in a logical sequence, not treated as mere toys, as they serve as scientific tools for children to explore concepts. Schools that are not serious about the Montessori approach often opt for low-quality materials from dubious suppliers, which can lead to inaccuracies in learning. Additionally, some schools claim to be Montessori while incorporating smart boards, TV screens, or tablets into their classrooms, contrary to the hands-on learning approach practiced in authentic Montessori environments worldwide.


2) Montessori Credentialed Directresses

Professional training courses ranging from 6 to 12 months are available for adults seeking to become Montessori Guides or Directresses. The primary role of the adult is to guide each child toward purposeful activity based on individual observations of readiness, pace, and interests. It is essential for adults working in Montessori environments to have undergone rigorous training from a reputable institute that upholds authentic Montessori standards. They must possess a deep understanding of the purpose of materials, their presentations, child psychology and developmental needs to effectively guide children in Montessori settings. When untrained or inadequately trained adults are responsible for children in such environments, it not only disadvantages the child but also does a disservice to both the child and the parents.


3) Mixed Age Grouping

Dr. Montessori's stages of development range from 0-3, 3-6, 6-12, and 12-18 years. One hallmark of the Montessori Method is the integration of children of different ages within the same environment, fostering mixed-age groups. This approach allows younger children to learn from and be inspired by older peers, while older children reinforce their learning by teaching concepts and developing leadership skills. Children progress individually at their own pace, promoting cooperation rather than competition—a model mirroring real-world interactions across ages and personalities. Montessori schools offering age-based categorizations like playgroups or level-based divisions are considered inauthentic. Without a 3-year mixed-age grouping, schools claiming to follow Montessori principles cannot fully implement the method's philosophy.


4) Uninterrupted Work Period - freedom to explore and think concepts more deeply rather than feel rushed and pressured to fit more into their time

In Montessori education, children engage extensively with Montessori materials throughout the school day, including a recommended 3-hour work period for the 3-6 age group. This structured work cycle involves choosing, completing, and cleaning up materials, fostering deep concentration and inner peace. However, separating children from materials or restricting access undermines the method's effectiveness. Authentic Montessori environments accommodate a maximum of 35 mixed-aged children with a full set of materials, unlike Montessori labs, which lack multiple environments. In non-Montessori schools, packed schedules of adult-driven activities limit children's growth, whereas authentic Montessori environments prioritize self-directed learning and lifelong joy. Montessori is not just a temporary activity but a way of life embraced by both children and adults in authentic Montessori schools.


5) Respect for Children - Freedom of Choice, Independence, Cooperation, Intrinsic motivation

Dr. Montessori stressed the importance of respecting children, which involves acknowledging their needs and granting them autonomy within reasonable boundaries. This fosters responsibility and self-discipline, qualities that develop gradually. In authentic Montessori environments, children engage in self-directed, intrinsically motivated activities, without external praise or negative reinforcement. They learn independence through ample opportunities for practice and collaboration in mixed-age settings, where competition is replaced by cooperation. Adults consciously establish clear limits, promote choice, and support uninterrupted concentration to nurture these essential life skills. Any Montessori setting that fails to prioritize these core competencies merely pays lip service to the method, resulting in the loss of a child's potential during these critical early years.


It is quite instructive for all parents interested in Montessori education to watch this advisory below from Global TV in Toronto, Canada about "How to identify a real Montessori school":

:


1,212 views1 comment

Recent Posts

See All

1件のコメント


Sumegha Kapoor
Sumegha Kapoor
2022年8月08日

Very very well written article. 👏

いいね!
bottom of page